The Strategy Stress Test: Which Assumptions Could Break Your Growth Plan?
Share this post
Brought to you by Emergent Africa
Why the greatest threat to your 2027 strategy may be an assumption your leadership team has never properly challenged
The assumptions behind the ambition
Every corporate growth strategy contains assumptions.
Some are explicit: expected market growth, revenue targets, operating margins, capital expenditure, productivity improvements and anticipated returns on investment.
Others are less visible.
Customers will continue buying at the expected rate. Competitors will behave predictably. Infrastructure will be sufficiently reliable. Critical skills will remain available. Technology investments will deliver their promised benefits. The organisation will execute its priorities within the agreed timelines.
Perhaps the most dangerous assumption is that the business environment will remain sufficiently close to the one anticipated when the strategy was approved.
The problem is not that executives make assumptions. Strategic planning would be impossible without them.
The problem arises when assumptions gradually become accepted as facts, particularly when they sit beneath ambitious financial commitments.
A board may approve a five-year growth strategy supported by compelling market research, detailed financial modelling and a persuasive investment case.
The CEO may have confidence in the strategic direction. The CFO may be satisfied with the financial projections. Business-unit executives may have committed to their performance targets.
Yet none of this guarantees that the underlying assumptions have been adequately tested.
What happens if market demand grows at half the anticipated rate?
What if the projected margin improvement does not materialise?
What if a critical transformation programme takes eighteen months rather than nine?
What if capital becomes more expensive, customer behaviour changes, or a competitor moves faster than expected?
And, perhaps more importantly, how early would the organisation recognise that one of its critical assumptions was becoming invalid?
These are not simply risk-management questions.
They are fundamental questions about the quality of strategy, the reliability of decision-making and the organisation’s ability to deliver sustainable growth.
As South African companies prepare to execute their 2027 priorities, the distinction between an ambitious strategy and a resilient one deserves renewed attention.
1. Why strategies need a more rigorous test
Global consulting research offers considerable evidence that developing a strategy and possessing a strategy capable of delivering superior performance are not the same thing.
In its July 2025 research, How Strategy Champions Win, McKinsey examined the quality of corporate strategy using its established Ten Tests of Strategy framework.
The findings were revealing.
In a survey conducted in 2024–2025, only 21% of executives reported that their strategies passed four or more of the ten tests. In McKinsey’s earlier 2010 research, the equivalent figure was 35%.
The surveys were conducted at different times with different respondent groups, so the comparison should be interpreted as an indication rather than a controlled measure of deterioration.
Nevertheless, the findings point to an important concern: many organisations may be operating with strategies that have not been sufficiently challenged.
McKinsey’s tests examine whether a strategy addresses questions such as competitive advantage, market dynamics, uncertainty, meaningful resource allocation and the organisation’s ability to translate decisions into action.
The underlying message is clear.
A strategy should be assessed not only by the quality of its presentation or the ambition of its targets, but also by the strength of its underlying logic.
Boston Consulting Group reached a complementary conclusion in its June 2025 paper, Strategic and Annual Planning in Volatile Times: What Every CEO Should Know.
BCG argued that waiting for greater certainty before making strategic decisions can place organisations at a competitive disadvantage.
Instead, executives should understand their revenue drivers, test their assumptions under multiple scenarios and adopt rolling forecasts that allow them to respond as circumstances change.
The objective is to identify a strategy capable of performing across different operating conditions — one that can, in BCG’s terminology, “win in all weathers”.
Deloitte’s September 2025 global research into board and C-suite collaboration similarly found that 71% of respondents identified strategic risk oversight and scenario planning as areas where board oversight could contribute most to organisational resilience.
These findings suggest that strategic resilience is increasingly a leadership and governance responsibility rather than a specialist risk-management exercise.
PwC’s 2026 Africa CEO Survey adds another dimension.
Based on responses from more than 150 African CEOs, the survey found that 81% expected economic conditions in their markets to improve, but only 47% were confident about revenue growth over the following twelve months.
Furthermore, 51% of respondents concentrated their attention on activities with time horizons shorter than one year, while only 15% focused on planning five years ahead.
This creates a strategic tension.
Business leaders recognise the need for long-term growth, yet operational pressures can restrict the time available to examine the assumptions on which that growth depends.
As PwC Africa CEO Dion Shango observed:
“Strategies cannot be static”
The implication is significant.
Strategic plans should be treated as evolving investment and execution hypotheses, not fixed commitments that remain valid merely because they were approved.
Sources: McKinsey (2025); BCG (2025); Deloitte (2025); PwC Africa (2026).
2. The South African growth equation is particularly sensitive to assumptions
South African businesses have become experienced at operating amid structural constraints and uncertainty.
Energy availability, transport logistics, infrastructure performance, currency movements, regulatory complexity, financing costs and uneven consumer demand all influence the commercial environment.
These pressures do not affect every business in the same way.
A mining company may be particularly exposed to export logistics, commodity prices and exchange rates.
A manufacturing business may be sensitive to production capacity, imported inputs, electricity costs and labour productivity.
A retailer may be more vulnerable to household purchasing power, price sensitivity and consumer credit conditions.
A healthcare group may face different assumptions concerning medical scheme membership, reimbursement, clinical capacity and regulatory change.
Yet the common challenge is that critical assumptions frequently sit outside the organisation’s direct control.
The South African Reserve Bank’s October 2026 Monetary Policy Review projected economic growth of approximately 1.2% for 2026, with a gradual improvement towards 2% by 2029.
The review also reported upward pressure on inflation, with headline inflation expected to remain elevated into 2027, and a policy rate of 7.25% following cumulative increases during the review period.
For corporate leadership teams, these conditions have direct implications for revenue forecasts, financing costs, capital allocation and margin expectations.
A growth strategy built around rapidly improving domestic demand, declining funding costs or stable input prices could encounter substantial pressure if those conditions fail to materialise.
Equally, organisations that assume infrastructure problems will remain unchanged could underestimate the opportunities created by targeted reforms and operational improvements.
The challenge is therefore not simply to construct a pessimistic outlook.
It is to distinguish between assumptions that are supported by credible evidence, those that represent reasonable estimates and those that are essentially optimistic expectations.
EY-Parthenon’s June 2026 research on South African CEO sentiment reinforces this need for balance.
Its findings describe business leaders pursuing growth while becoming more selective about investment, execution discipline and financial resilience.
The resulting leadership imperative is to protect current performance while developing opportunities for future growth.
However, this requires a more rigorous understanding of the assumptions supporting both objectives.
A strategy designed for growth must also be capable of surviving conditions less favourable than those originally anticipated.
3. The hidden assumption problem
Why do important assumptions escape sufficient scrutiny?
The answer is rarely that executive teams lack intelligence or experience.
More often, it reflects how corporate strategies are developed, approved and monitored.
Assumptions become embedded in financial models
A financial forecast may contain hundreds of calculations, but only a relatively small number of variables account for a substantial proportion of the anticipated result.
These could include revenue growth, gross margin, customer retention, capacity utilisation or expected productivity gains.
Once the spreadsheet has been reviewed and approved, attention often shifts towards delivery against the resulting targets rather than continued examination of the assumptions that produced them.
Organisational consensus discourages challenge
Executives invest time and professional credibility in strategic proposals.
As a result, questioning an important assumption may be interpreted as questioning the judgement of the executive responsible for it.
Leadership teams can unintentionally reward confidence and alignment more than constructive disagreement.
Different functions work with different assumptions
Finance may assume a certain exchange rate.
Procurement may use another assumption in supplier negotiations.
Sales may be forecasting volumes based on market intelligence that has not yet reached operations.
Human resources may have staffing plans that are inconsistent with the timing of a major expansion programme.
Each function may have a perfectly reasonable perspective.
The difficulty arises when these perspectives are not reconciled into a single, coherent enterprise plan.
Performance reporting is often backward-looking
Monthly reports typically explain what has happened.
They are less effective at identifying the early signals suggesting that an assumption supporting future performance is becoming invalid.
By the time revenue, EBITDA or cash flow materially deviates from plan, the opportunity for a relatively inexpensive correction may already have disappeared.
Assumptions have no clear owners
A business initiative may have an accountable executive, but the underlying assumptions may not.
Who is responsible for validating projected market growth?
Who confirms that anticipated benefits from an investment are achievable?
Who decides when evidence requires an assumption to be revised?
Without clear ownership, strategic assumptions can remain unchallenged long after the operating environment has changed.
The cumulative result is what could be described as an assumption gap: the difference between the world for which a strategy was designed and the world in which the business must actually execute it.
The wider this gap becomes, the greater the risk that the organisation continues allocating resources to a growth plan whose economics are no longer valid.
4. Ten assumptions every growth strategy should stress-test
A meaningful strategy stress test begins by identifying the assumptions that would have the greatest consequences if proved wrong.
Although priorities differ across industries, ten areas deserve particular attention.
Assumption 1: The market will grow as expected
Most growth plans include assumptions about market size, customer demand and anticipated industry expansion.
The danger is that growth expectations become extrapolations of previous performance or accepted market forecasts.
A company targeting 10% annual revenue growth in a market expanding by 3% needs to explain precisely where the additional growth will originate.
Is it expecting market-share gains, price increases, acquisitions, new products or geographic expansion?
Each has different risks and execution requirements.
Stress-test question: What happens to our growth plan if addressable market demand is 30% below our forecast, and how much market share would we then need to gain?
Assumption 2: Customers will behave as anticipated
Customer behaviour can change faster than strategic planning cycles.
Price sensitivity may increase. Procurement processes may become more demanding. Customers may consolidate their supplier relationships or change their product preferences.
A business that assumes stable retention rates, average transaction values or customer acquisition costs could find its forecast deteriorating before revenue results reveal the underlying problem.
Stress-test question: Which changes in customer purchasing behaviour would invalidate our commercial assumptions, and what early evidence would reveal them?
Assumption 3: Margins will improve as projected
Many growth strategies assume some combination of operating leverage, procurement savings, productivity improvement and price recovery.
These improvements often depend on multiple initiatives working together.
If volume growth slows, input costs rise or efficiency gains are delayed, the anticipated margin expansion may disappear.
A relatively small change in operating margin can have a disproportionate effect on EBITDA, free cash flow and shareholder returns.
Stress-test question: Which three assumptions are most important to our projected margin improvement, and what happens if two deteriorate simultaneously?
Assumption 4: Competitors will respond predictably
A strategy may assume that competitors will maintain current pricing, invest at familiar levels or continue serving established customer segments.
These are potentially dangerous assumptions.
Competitors may respond aggressively to new entrants, use technology to change their cost structures, acquire capabilities or shift their commercial models.
Competitive dynamics are particularly relevant where organisations expect growth through market-share gains.
Stress-test question: What could a well-funded, digitally enabled or unusually aggressive competitor do that would undermine our growth thesis?
Assumption 5: Capital will remain available at an acceptable cost
Growth often requires financing.
Capital expansion, acquisitions, technology transformation and working-capital requirements may all depend on assumptions about interest rates, debt capacity and access to funding.
A project that appears attractive under one financing scenario may produce substantially weaker returns under another.
This is especially important for capital-intensive companies and businesses with refinancing requirements.
Stress-test question: Which investments remain financially attractive if our funding costs increase, cash conversion weakens or available debt capacity declines?
Assumption 6: Infrastructure and supply chains will support delivery
An organisation may have sufficient customer demand and financial resources but still fail to deliver because of capacity limitations.
These could involve energy supply, logistics, ports, equipment availability, distribution networks, supplier concentration or operational bottlenecks.
The strategic issue is not simply the probability of disruption.
It is the dependency between growth expectations and the infrastructure required to fulfil them.
Stress-test question: Which single infrastructure or supply-chain dependency could prevent us from delivering our growth commitments, even if market demand meets expectations?
Assumption 7: Technology investments will generate the promised returns
Digital transformation and artificial intelligence feature prominently in corporate growth plans.
However, the benefits frequently depend on data quality, process redesign, employee adoption, integration and effective governance.
PwC’s 2026 Global CEO Survey found that only 12% of CEOs reported AI delivering both revenue and cost benefits, while 56% reported no significant financial benefits at that stage.
This does not imply that AI lacks commercial value.
It demonstrates why technology investment cases need measurable benefits, explicit dependencies and realistic implementation assumptions.
Stress-test question: What if our technology investment delivers only half its expected commercial benefits, or requires substantially more time and investment to scale?
Assumption 8: People and organisational capacity will support the strategy
Growth depends on leadership capacity, scarce skills, employee engagement, change readiness and effective collaboration.
An organisation may approve several transformation programmes without fully assessing whether the same executives, specialists and operational teams are expected to deliver all of them simultaneously.
The resulting capacity constraints can create delays, burnout, reduced productivity and deteriorating execution quality.
Stress-test question: Have we established that the organisation has the leadership capacity, skills and employee resilience to deliver all approved strategic priorities concurrently?
Assumption 9: Regulatory, sustainability and stakeholder expectations will remain manageable
Growth strategies increasingly depend on compliance with environmental standards, customer sustainability requirements, industry regulations and changing stakeholder expectations.
These considerations can influence operating costs, customer eligibility, access to international markets and capital expenditure.
For certain exporters and industrial businesses, evolving carbon-related and supply-chain requirements may change the economics of products and markets.
The relevant assumptions should be specific to each organisation’s jurisdictions, customers and regulatory exposure.
Stress-test question: Which regulatory or sustainability developments could materially change our cost structure, market access or investment requirements?
Assumption 10: The organisation will execute at the required speed
This may be the most important assumption of all.
A strategy can be directionally correct, commercially attractive and financially well funded but still fail because execution takes longer than anticipated.
Dependencies between departments, unclear accountability, delayed decisions, inconsistent reporting and competing priorities can gradually erode the business case.
A six-month delay in a strategically important initiative may affect revenue, cash flow and the returns expected from subsequent investments.
Stress-test question: What happens to our growth plan if our three most important strategic initiatives deliver six to twelve months later than scheduled?
These ten questions move the discussion beyond whether the strategy is attractive.
They ask whether it is credible, resilient and executable.
5. From scenario planning to a genuine strategy stress test
Traditional scenario planning is useful, but it does not automatically deliver a sufficiently rigorous assessment of strategic resilience.
Some organisations develop three financial forecasts: optimistic, expected and pessimistic.
They adjust revenue growth, operating costs and margins before presenting the results.
Although valuable, this approach can leave the underlying strategic logic largely untouched.
A genuine stress test should examine not only how the financial results change but also why they change, which strategic choices become invalid and what management should do differently.
A practical process involves six connected steps.
Step 1: Identify the assumptions that matter most
Begin with the organisation’s strategic objectives, capital allocation commitments and expected value creation.
Work backwards.
What must be true for each outcome to be achieved?
If the company expects to double operating profit over five years, identify how much of that increase depends on volume, price, margin improvement, acquisitions and operational efficiencies.
Not every assumption deserves the same attention.
Prioritise those with the greatest potential impact on enterprise value, cash flow and strategic delivery.
Step 2: Establish the evidence supporting each assumption
Every critical assumption should have a clearly defined evidence base.
This may include historical performance, market research, customer data, competitor intelligence, financial analysis or operational capacity assessments.
Leadership teams should distinguish between:
Verified assumptions: Supported by reliable evidence and recent validation.
Estimated assumptions: Plausible, but dependent on incomplete information.
Speculative assumptions: Based principally on management judgement or desired outcomes.
A speculative assumption is not necessarily wrong.
It should, however, be recognised and managed differently from one supported by strong evidence.
Step 3: Model sensitivity and interacting risks
Test how the expected outcomes change when individual assumptions deteriorate.
Then test combinations.
For example, weaker customer demand, higher funding costs and slower productivity improvements may each be manageable individually.
Together, they could substantially weaken financial performance.
Executives should consider the interaction between risks, rather than assuming all variables move independently.
The critical output is not the most dramatic downside scenario.
It is an understanding of which combinations of events would materially damage the growth strategy.
Step 4: Reverse-test the strategy
Instead of asking what might happen under an assumed scenario, begin with an unacceptable outcome.
For example:
EBITDA falls 20% below plan.
A major investment fails to meet its cost-of-capital hurdle.
Cash conversion weakens enough to threaten essential capital commitments.
A strategic programme misses its delivery date by twelve months.
A critical business unit loses a substantial customer relationship.
Then determine which combination of assumptions would produce that outcome.
This technique, commonly known as reverse stress testing, makes strategic vulnerabilities easier to identify.
It can also reveal that apparently minor changes across several variables may be more consequential than a single major disruption.
Step 5: Define decision triggers before they are needed
A stress test becomes commercially useful when it informs decisions.
For each major assumption, leadership should establish indicators that provide sufficient warning to act.
For example:
If customer order intake remains below a defined threshold for three consecutive months, the organisation may reconsider expansion expenditure.
If a transformation programme misses a critical milestone, management may reassess its benefits forecast and reallocate resources.
If forecast operating costs exceed a predetermined range, procurement, pricing or operating-model interventions may be activated.
These actions should have accountable owners and appropriate decision rights.
The objective is to establish a connection between evidence, management response and strategic outcomes.
Step 6: Integrate the test into ongoing execution
A strategy stress test should not be performed once, filed away and revisited at the next annual planning session.
Critical assumptions need regular validation.
BCG advocates rolling forecasts and continual testing of assumptions as conditions change.
This requires a management process that connects strategic objectives, financial expectations, performance indicators, delivery milestones and executive accountability.
The organisation must be able to distinguish between a temporary performance deviation and evidence that the strategy itself needs revision.
That distinction is essential.
A missed target may be an execution problem. A broken assumption may be a strategy problem. The management response should not automatically be the same.
6. What a broken assumption could cost: an illustrative example
Consider a hypothetical South African industrial group preparing its next financial year.
Its approved growth strategy anticipates:
Annual revenue of R12 billion.
An EBITDA margin of 15%.
Forecast EBITDA of R1.8 billion.
The strategy depends on stable customer volumes, operating efficiencies and a modest improvement in the cost environment.
Now consider a downside scenario in which revenue is 6% below plan while the EBITDA margin falls by two percentage points.
The new outcome is:
Revenue: R11.28 billion.
EBITDA margin: 13%.
EBITDA: R1.466 billion.
This represents an EBITDA shortfall of approximately R334 million, or 18.5% below plan.
The example is illustrative, not a forecast for any particular company.
It demonstrates how relatively modest deviations in two assumptions can combine to produce a material reduction in earnings.
The consequences may extend beyond EBITDA.
Lower cash generation could delay investment, weaken returns, constrain working capital and affect the organisation’s capacity to pursue additional growth opportunities.
The leadership questions become more interesting than the calculation itself.
Would management have identified the underlying changes early enough?
Which projects would continue to receive funding?
Which commitments would be reconsidered?
What alternative actions could preserve long-term strategic value?
And would the board have confidence that the executive team understood the situation before the financial results made it obvious?
The purpose of a stress test is not to predict exactly when the downside scenario will occur.
It is to ensure that management understands the potential consequences and possesses credible options if it does.
7. Why trustworthy data is essential to strategic resilience
A strategy stress test is only as reliable as the information supporting it.
This is an important consideration for large organisations operating across multiple business units, systems, markets and reporting structures.
Financial data may be consolidated centrally while customer, supplier, operational and project information remains fragmented.
Different departments may use inconsistent definitions for the same performance indicators.
Customer information may be duplicated. Supplier records may be incomplete. Product classifications may vary across systems.
These problems can create misleading analysis even when the underlying financial models are technically sophisticated.
Deloitte’s May 2026 research, Data Credibility and Governance, emphasises that scenario planning and agile governance depend on reliable data.
Its analysis of finance leadership research found that 58% of respondents identified advanced scenario planning or more agile governance as among the most important actions for navigating economic and geopolitical uncertainty.
But sophisticated analytical tools do not compensate automatically for unreliable source information.
For a strategy stress test to work, decision-makers need confidence in the data used to assess assumptions.
This requires clear definitions, traceable data sources, appropriate governance, identifiable owners and effective reconciliation between operational and financial information.
Master data management becomes relevant because it creates a more consistent foundation for information about customers, suppliers, products, organisational entities and other critical business dimensions.
Decision intelligence builds on this foundation by helping executives connect information to choices.
The commercial objective is straightforward:
Executives should be able to understand not only whether performance is changing, but which assumptions are responsible, what the likely consequences are and which interventions offer the greatest value.
Without that capability, organisations may have substantial quantities of data while remaining unable to answer the questions that matter most.
8. The execution challenge: knowing when to change course
Identifying a weakening assumption is only the beginning.
The harder challenge is changing course without undermining organisational alignment or creating confusion.
This requires a distinction between strategic direction and the route taken to achieve it.
A company may remain committed to growing in a particular market while modifying its investment sequence, distribution approach, pricing structure or operating model.
A business may preserve its long-term digital ambition while changing implementation priorities because a key technology dependency has proved more complex than anticipated.
An organisation may continue pursuing international expansion while delaying one market entry and accelerating another.
These are not necessarily strategic failures.
They can be examples of disciplined strategic adaptation.
However, adaptation becomes difficult when strategic commitments are disconnected from day-to-day execution.
If accountability is fragmented, executives may disagree about which indicators matter or whether an initiative should be continued.
If performance information is inconsistent, decision-making slows.
If strategic initiatives are reviewed separately from financial assumptions, corrective action may be poorly targeted.
This is where a connected strategy execution approach becomes particularly important.
From annual approval to continuous strategic management
An effective strategy execution framework should make the relationships between objectives, initiatives, assumptions, financial outcomes and accountable executives visible.
It should enable leadership teams to answer questions such as:
Which strategic initiatives depend on assumptions that are now deteriorating?
What proportion of planned earnings growth relies on those initiatives?
Are the required milestones being achieved?
Are problems caused by execution delays, capacity limitations or a change in market conditions?
Which management decisions are required, and who has authority to make them?
Which trade-offs would improve the probability of achieving the organisation’s most important outcomes?
The benefit is not simply improved reporting.
It is stronger decision discipline.
Rather than monitoring a collection of disconnected projects and financial indicators, management can assess whether the organisation is still pursuing a credible route to its strategic objectives.
9. Turning strategy assumptions into a management discipline
A practical approach is to create a formal strategic assumptions register as part of the organisation’s strategy execution process.
For every assumption that could materially affect growth, the register should capture:
The assumption: What management believes must happen.
The strategic dependency: Which objectives, investments or initiatives rely on it.
The evidence: Information supporting the assumption and its reliability.
The sensitivity: Financial or operational consequences if it changes.
The leading indicators: Early signals that the assumption may be weakening.
The trigger: A defined threshold for management attention or intervention.
The owner: The executive accountable for validating it.
The response: Available management actions and required decision rights.
The review date: When the assumption must be reassessed.
This creates a more disciplined connection between strategy, risk, capital allocation and operational performance.
Not every assumption needs to be reviewed monthly.
Stable assumptions may require less frequent validation, while highly sensitive market, funding or operational assumptions could warrant more regular monitoring.
The key is proportionality.
Executives should focus their attention on the assumptions that have the greatest ability to change the organisation’s commercial trajectory.
What boards should expect
Boards do not need every operational assumption.
They need a concise view of the most material strategic dependencies.
A useful quarterly strategy review could include:
The five to ten assumptions most critical to achieving approved growth objectives.
Changes in confidence or supporting evidence since the previous review.
Financial and operational sensitivities associated with those changes.
Strategic initiatives at risk because assumptions are weakening.
Management decisions taken or recommended in response.
The remaining strategic options available if conditions deteriorate further.
This approach changes the character of board reporting.
Instead of focusing predominantly on whether targets have been met, it asks whether the conditions required to achieve future targets remain credible.
10. A practical 90-day strategy stress-test programme
Organisations do not need to redesign their entire strategy management process before beginning.
A focused ninety-day programme can establish the foundations.
Days 1–30: Make the assumptions visible
The first stage should identify the principal growth drivers and dependencies.
Finance, strategy and business-unit leaders should work together to examine approved plans and investment cases.
The objective is to identify the assumptions most likely to influence revenue, profitability, cash flow, return on invested capital and strategic delivery.
Management should also identify gaps in evidence and inconsistencies between functional plans.
At the end of this stage, the organisation should have an agreed list of material assumptions, their owners and the decisions they influence.
Days 31–60: Test the strategy under pressure
The second stage should examine the sensitivity of the growth plan.
This involves developing plausible downside and upside scenarios, testing interacting risks and determining the conditions under which strategic commitments become unattractive or unachievable.
Financial, operational and strategic consequences should be assessed together.
Importantly, the programme should also examine execution assumptions: delivery timelines, critical skills, dependencies, organisational capacity and decision-making processes.
The output should be a clear view of the organisation’s most significant strategic vulnerabilities and its capacity to respond.
Days 61–90: Connect the findings to executive decisions
The final stage should translate the analysis into management action.
Leadership should establish leading indicators, intervention thresholds, governance responsibilities and a review cadence.
Strategic initiatives and investment priorities may need to be adjusted.
The executive team should also agree on the conditions that would justify accelerating, slowing, redesigning or discontinuing specific initiatives.
The result is not another strategy document.
It is a more dynamic management capability that allows the organisation to protect performance while retaining the flexibility to pursue growth.
11. Seven questions every board should ask before entering 2027
As executive teams finalise their priorities for 2027, boards and CEOs should consider seven questions.
1. Which five assumptions have the greatest influence on our growth and earnings forecasts?
Can management identify them immediately, or are they buried inside financial models and business-unit plans?
2. Which assumptions are supported by strong evidence, and which depend primarily on management optimism?
Have material assumptions been independently challenged?
3. What would need to happen for our growth strategy to become financially or operationally unattractive?
Have we identified the conditions under which we should reconsider a major investment or strategic initiative?
4. How would our business perform if two or three significant assumptions deteriorated simultaneously?
Do our scenario models account for interacting risks rather than isolated events?
5. How quickly would we recognise that an assumption had become invalid?
Are we monitoring appropriate leading indicators, or waiting for financial performance to deteriorate?
6. Can we connect changes in assumptions to strategic initiatives, accountable executives and financial consequences?
Do our information systems and management processes support that level of visibility?
7. Do we have the discipline to change course when the evidence requires it?
Are decision rights, escalation processes and resource reallocation mechanisms sufficiently clear?
These questions are relevant to virtually every major organisation, irrespective of its industry.
More importantly, they encourage leadership teams to confront the uncertainties that matter before those uncertainties become financial problems.
12. Where Emergent Africa can add value
At Emergent Africa, we believe the quality of a strategy should be assessed not only by the ambition of its objectives but by the organisation’s ability to make informed choices, execute consistently and adapt when circumstances change.
Our work across strategy, strategy execution, decision intelligence and data management is directed towards helping organisations connect these capabilities.
Through strategic analysis and execution advisory, organisations can establish greater clarity around strategic priorities, critical assumptions, delivery requirements and accountability.
Our Meridian Strategy Execution Platform is designed to support a more connected approach to strategy execution by linking strategic objectives, initiatives, performance measures and accountable owners.
This creates a stronger management foundation for monitoring delivery, understanding dependencies and identifying where intervention may be required.
Our decision intelligence capabilities help leadership teams interpret relevant information and evaluate business choices with greater discipline.
Our Master Data Management as a Service capability addresses the information foundations needed for consistent analysis across business functions, while our sustainability and reporting capabilities can support visibility into material ESG-related obligations and performance.
Together, these capabilities support a broader objective: helping executives move from periodic strategic planning towards continuous, evidence-led strategic management.
The principle is simple.
A growth strategy should be clear enough to execute, measurable enough to manage and flexible enough to adapt.
Conclusion: The most valuable question may be the one nobody has asked
Corporate strategies are often presented with considerable precision.
Revenue targets are defined. Capital allocations are approved. Performance commitments are agreed. Executives are assigned responsibility for delivering results.
Yet the precision of these commitments can create a misleading sense of certainty.
The future remains uncertain, regardless of how carefully a strategy has been constructed.
Markets change. Customers behave differently. Competitors innovate. Costs move. Technology evolves. People and organisations encounter capacity constraints.
The objective of strategic leadership is not to eliminate uncertainty.
It is to understand which uncertainties matter, test the assumptions that carry the greatest financial and operational consequences, and develop the capability to respond intelligently.
The strongest growth strategies are therefore not necessarily those built around the most confident forecasts.
They are those that remain commercially credible when reality begins to diverge from expectations.
For South African boards and executive teams preparing for 2027, the challenge is particularly relevant.
Before asking whether the organisation is on track to achieve its growth plan, leadership should ask a more fundamental question:
Which assumptions must remain true for the growth plan to work — and what will we do if they do not?
That may be the most important strategy discussion of the coming year.
About Emergent Africa
Emergent Africa is a management consultancy focused on helping organisations strengthen strategic decision-making, improve strategy execution and build the capabilities required for sustainable business performance.
Our expertise includes strategy and strategy execution, decision intelligence, master data management, ESG consulting and reporting, and organisational and employee wellbeing.
Our approach combines executive-level advisory experience with practical capabilities designed to connect strategic ambition to measurable business outcomes.
For a strategic conversation about testing the assumptions behind your organisation’s growth plan, connect with Emergent Africa.
Research and references
McKinsey & Company, How Strategy Champions Win, 14 July 2025. Research on strategy quality, the Ten Tests of Strategy and execution capabilities.
Boston Consulting Group, Strategic and Annual Planning in Volatile Times: What Every CEO Should Know, 17 June 2025. Scenario analysis, business drivers, forecasting and strategic investment decisions.
https://www.bcg.com/publications/2025/strategic-and-annual-planning-in-chaotic-times
Deloitte, How Board and C-suite Collaboration Can Build Organisational Resilience, 30 September 2025. Global research on board oversight, scenario planning and organisational resilience.
Deloitte Insights, Data Credibility and Governance, 27 May 2026. Data reliability, governance and decision-making in scenario planning.
https://www.deloitte.com/us/en/insights/topics/business-strategy-growth/data-governance.html
PwC, 29th Global CEO Survey: Africa Perspective, February 2026. African CEO confidence, investment intentions, strategic reinvention and leadership priorities.
https://www.pwc.co.za/en/publications/ceo-survey.html
PwC, 29th Global CEO Survey, January 2026. AI benefits, CEO confidence and business model reinvention.
https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/issues/c-suite-insights/ceo-survey.html
EY-Parthenon, What Will It Take to Win in a More Complex World?, 18 June 2026. South African CEO expectations and strategic responses to uncertainty.
https://www.ey.com/en_za/ceo/south-africa-ceo-outlook-may-2026
South African Reserve Bank, Monetary Policy Review, October 2026. Macroeconomic growth, inflation and monetary policy assumptions.
Research note: Survey findings reflect the respective respondent populations and reporting periods. They should not be interpreted as universal probabilities. The financial scenario and proposed management framework in this paper are illustrative Emergent Africa analyses, not findings attributed to the research organisations.